Carbon impacts from conversion of arable to grassland?

According to PAS 2050 Specification for lifecycle assessment of GHG emissions the increase in Soil Carbon from converting arable land to grassland is 7 t/ha for 20 years. This seems very high compared to other evidence and sources - eg SRUC report here - https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/media/3046/soil-carbon-and-land-use-in-scotland.pdf

Is there something wrong?

Discussion

I’ve not looked into the detail, but believe the land use change elements of the specification come from IPCC LULUCF inventory methodology.  Data from a review by Dawson & Smith (2006) suggests that conversion from tillage land to grassland can increase soil carbon by between 1.1 and 7 t CO2e/ha/yr which equates to 0.3 - 2 t/ha/yr carbon, but I must admit the 2t/ha/yr seems rather high. At the lower end this would therefore be about 6 t/ha over the 20 year period, which is similar to the 7 t/ha in the standard.

Disclaimer

Please ensure that you have proof-read your content. Pages are not edited further once submitted and will go live immediately.